Notes from people who sat through oscillator comparison workshops, divergence clinics, and private chart reviews — including the moments that felt awkward.
These comments come from traders who attended sessions at the Creek Street studio. We ask for specifics — which workshop, which sticking point — rather than star ratings.
The September intensive finally forced me to stop layering four oscillators until one agreed with my bias. We spent an hour on a single BHP chart where RSI, Stochastic, and MACD told three different stories — uncomfortable, but that is exactly what I needed.
I still prefer Stochastic for timing, and the facilitator did not try to talk me out of it. What changed is I now wait for MACD histogram confirmation on swing holds, which cut a few premature exits on CBA.
Private chart review was blunt about my CCI settings being too tight for the four-hour FX charts I trade. We rewrote my comparison checklist; it is taped above my desk. The session ran a little over, which I appreciated.
Room was a bit cool and the lunch break felt short, but the afternoon personal chart slots were the real value. Seeing my own AUDUSD setup marked up beside a classmate’s iron ore names made the oscillator differences stick.
Longer client stories
From indicator stacking to a two-oscillator rule
A Fortitude Valley day trader arrived with five oscillators on every chart and a habit of entering only when “most of them” agreed. Across two Intensive sessions we stripped the layout to RSI and MACD, documented when Stochastic was allowed as a tie-break, and practised on three weeks of ASX 200 five-minute bars. Four weeks later they reported fewer midday reversals taken against a rising MACD histogram — not because the indicators changed, but because the comparison order did.
Divergence clinic after a rough earnings week
A position trader who held through a noisy reporting season booked the half-day clinic to understand why RSI flashed bearish divergence while price made higher highs on two resource names. We walked the exact bars, compared Stochastic’s faster trips into oversold, and drafted a rule: treat RSI divergence as a watch alert, not an exit, until MACD line slope flattens. They still hold longer than some classmates, and that is fine — the workshop goal was clearer language for the disagreement, not a single trading style.
We use essential cookies to keep the site working and optional analytics cookies to understand which workshop pages help visitors. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies.